Yesterday I witnessed the latest chapter in a what has been potentially the worst football season ever for Newcastle United. All fans are now shouting for Steve McClaren to be sacked, or to fall on his sword. But is that actually the answer? OK, so let’s put aside the fact that Steve may have picked the wrong starting eleven. He picked eleven very well paid footballers who ought to be able to play as a team regardless of management decisions.
Instead, it looked like eleven individuals, all acting as individuals, with no connection whatsoever. It was diabolical to watch; and probably would have been funny if we weren’t second from bottom of the premier league. Shelvey was potentially the best player overall, as at least it looked like he was trying. And as for Sissoko, the less said about his performance, the better. I have no idea what the players get up to during training, but I don’t think it involves kicking a ball around, if yesterday’s activities are anything to go by. Maybe sitting around sipping coffee, and talking about the weather?
Let’s just examine what a football manager does before, and during a match. Firstly, he selects the team – the starting eleven plus the substitutes. And whilst the fans may not always like his selection, the fans don’t necessarily have all the facts at hand. For instance, player X may been experiencing an intermittent hurty index finger and therefore wouldn’t last the full 90 minutes. Secondly, the manager decides the formation and strategy. Again, this isn’t to everyone’s taste, but we’re not football managers.
But then, once the players are out on the pitch, there is very little the manager can do. He can shout and scream at the players, but that’s about it. At this point, it is up to the captain to make on-the-pitch decisions. The captain should be empowered to change things around a bit, if it’s clearly not working. That’s the captains job.
As fans, it is very easy to blame the manager, and, of course, he does have to take ultimate responsibility. But the players, too, have to shoulder some of it. They each get paid more money in a month that I earn in a year. Yet, they rarely admit how badly they have played, or accept any criticism whatsoever. They let the manager take it. I mean, after all, if Newcastle get relegated, the players will probably transfer to other clubs. And when they go home after an awful performance like yesterday, I’m sure the odd glass of expensive champagne, or whatever, will make things better.
But we still blame the manager.
Personally, I think the players should donate last week’s wages to charity, or maybe divide it up amongst the 50,000 fans that turn up week after week to watch them play.
Don’t get me wrong. I’m not defending Steve McClaren. I’m as angry and frustrated as the next fan. But what will sacking him achieve? He’ll probably be on a contract where he’ll get a large pay off for being sacked, and Newcastle will be without manager. And, to get someone else, will mean that Mike “every pound’s a prisoner” Ashley will have to splash out some cash. Also, will the next man in charge be any better?
I certainly don’t want to see Newcastle United get relegated, but I can’t see a way out of this mess. Maybe during the next week McClaren will part company with the club, and someone else will be brought in. But ultimately, will they be able to turn Newcastle’s misfortunes around.